Status: Age: 59 Faith: Islam Gender:
Zodiac: Joined: Oct 16, 2006
Posts: 3236 Location: Australia
Post subject: Sura 2 - Comments and Feedback ii
Salam all
Brother The sent me some feedback:
The wrote:
# okay, bud...i went thru those verses and i don't think there's much i would dispute! but i think u should retain the style of the quran; for eg: u have translated 2:12 as,
Salam mate
sure bro, if you think I flawed not to retain that style, please advice asap
[quote="The"]12- Nay, they are mischief-makers but they do not feel.
The wrote:
the verse is:
Ala innahum humu almufsidoona walakinla yashAAuroona
There was a "The" missing which I added it btw before I recieved your feedback, that is why what you had is not 100% identical to is currently posted, sorry mate
The wrote:
that is a question, even if for the sake of rhetoric, but it is, and i think u should also translate it as a question to preserve the style used in the quran! pickthall, sale, and rodwell have, among others, kept the same rhetoric which the quran uses in that verse! (-:
Sure, can you please put the verse down as you see it more proper, cheers
The wrote:
## also, u have translated "idha" as if; yes, it might not make much of a difference in the particular verses i am talkin' about, but i would prefer that u retain "when" and not go for "if" for "idha"
Ok so what you are saying that When fits more than If, great I have no problem with that, will change it inshaallah later today or tomorrowl
The wrote:
..and in "innalladhina kafaru," i believe the "inna" lends some emphasis, while u have simply translated it as "and those who disbelieve"...i would prefer that u add a similar emphasis using "surely" or "indeed" or something like that!
I agree, will do lateron inshaallah
The wrote:
..this is what i meant by retaining the style of the quran; however, if u feel otherwise then i have no problems with it, bud! (-:
not at all, I appreciate your feedback
The wrote:
# i have got some business to attend to, bud, and i am unlikely to be able to participate further! i will try to come on whenever possible, and i hope to see u carry on ur good work!
No probs mate, wheever you have time please come and give a hand
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum You cannot attach files in this forum You cannot download files in this forum
All times are GMT + 10 Hours Ported for PHP-Nuke by nukemods.com
